InsightsHealthcare & Pharma

Nigeria was short of vaccines, yet it crushed 1,066,214 donated doses.

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

A gift you can't use in time isn't a gift. Nigeria's health teams learned that the hard way.

In 2021, richer countries were giving away their spare doses for free. With a shortage across the continent, Nigeria said yes.

Some landed with only weeks left before they expired. The health minister, Osagie Ehanire, put it politely: "We appreciate the kind gesture of donors, but…" The "but" was the short shelf life.

Its health teams raced the doses to clinics and, by the ministry's own account, used most of them in time.

Still, 1,066,214 doses ran out. On 22 December 2021, Nigeria's primary health care agency crushed them at a dumpsite in Abuja, in public, so Nigerians could keep trusting their vaccines.

The WHO Guidelines for Medicine Donations (revised 2010) set the baseline at one year remaining on arrival. Some of these doses had weeks.

That December, Nigeria said it would no longer accept vaccines with a short shelf life. It was not alone: UNICEF's supply director, Etleva Kadilli, later told the European Parliament that more than 100 million donated doses had been refused in December alone, mostly over shelf life.

It is the 20 boxes of wedding sweets Aunty sends: the family finishes 6, the ants get 14. A depot that takes more than it can sell pays twice: to store it, then to destroy it.

So before accepting a delivery that expires soon (short-dated stock), run one sum: monthly use, times months left, minus stock on the shelf.

If the delivery fits inside that number, it will be consumed. If not, part of it is waste on arrival.

Accept short-dated stock only when all three hold:

  1. Consumption covers it: six-month average use, times months to expiry, less stock held, exceeds the quantity offered.
  2. Distribution fits: subtract the time to reach the last facility first.
  3. Price reflects risk: the discount is written into the contract, with a return clause.

Where the rule bends: count cold-chain items at half their remaining life. A sole-source product may pass on step 1 alone.

A low price on stock that expires is the highest price on the shelf.

Cheap stock that expires soon: count first, or say yes?

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.