InsightsProcurement & Tenders

In Canada, hospital doctors stopped admitting new patients, and their managers suspended three of them.

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

No contract foresees everything. Their next one named who decides when it can't: a doctor and a manager, together.

Island Health's hospitalists, the doctors who run inpatient care in two Victoria hospitals, had worked under four bitter contracts since 2000. The doctors felt squeezed; the managers doubted their hours. The doctors even joked that a rhododendron forest separated them from the managers.

After the fourth contract expired in mid-2014, the stand-off began: some stopped admitting emergency patients, and in March 2015 three were suspended.

One day a young doctor asked finance chief Kim Kerrone, "Why does administration dislike us so much?" She was shocked: nobody did. She recommended a formal relational contract, built on how the two sides work together, instead of more hard bargaining.

In May 2016, 12 administrators and nine hospitalists spent three days with a neutral facilitator. Most came with folded arms. Asked to grade each other, each side gave itself a B and the other a D.

The method rests on Oliver Hart's work, which won the 2016 economics Nobel: no contract can spell out every eventuality, so what matters is who decides when the unplanned comes. With David Frydlinger and Kate Vitasek, he writes six guiding principles, shared rules of conduct, into the contract for the moments its terms run out (Harvard Business Review, 2019).

Signed on 1 July 2018, the contract fixes rates, hours and a yearly maximum. Four joint teams, each co-chaired by a doctor and an administrator, decide the rest. "Before, we had no one to speak with," said Ken Smith, one of the hospitalists.

When the pandemic arrived in 2020, an eventuality no clause had foreseen, the contract already named who would decide: the joint teams.

Neighbours who share a borehole work the same way: they pick a referee early, because in the dry season nobody is polite.

A manufacturer on a multi-year framework agreement with a public buyer lives with the same gap: prices are fixed, shortages and currency moves are not. Name who decides before one hits.

A contract written for every eventuality fails at the first one nobody wrote down.

When your contract runs out of answers, who decides: both sides together, or the lawyers?

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.