InsightsHealthcare & Pharma

For six years, people slept beside breathing machines with a fault their maker knew about.

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

The first complaint is the cheapest day to act. And the kindest.

In 2021, Philips Respironics recalled 15 million sleep apnoea and ventilator devices. A sound-dampening foam inside could crumble and be breathed in. One 2011 complaint, reported by ProPublica, read: "Black shavings in the chamber."

The FDA later said the company knew of the foam problem, and of related complaints, by 2015 or earlier. Customers were not told until the recall in June 2021. About 2,000 nights passed in between.

By January 2024, the FDA had received more than 116,000 reports linked to the foam, including 561 reports of death. Philips disputes that its devices caused them.

It doesn't have to take years. In late September 1982, seven people died after taking Tylenol capsules laced with cyanide. Within a week, on 5 October, Johnson & Johnson recalled all 31 million bottles, about $100 million at retail. Experts said the brand was dead: its share fell from 37% to 7%. Within a year, in a new sealed pack, it was back near 30%.

One caveat: J&J was the victim of a crime, and its recovery owed as much to that new pack as to speed. A defect of your own is harder to disclose and costlier to sit on.

Why do firms wait? In 2022, Wenzheng Mao, Zhanyu Dong and Hsiao-Hui Lee modelled when a firm chooses to delay a recall. Delay grows more likely when the defect is spotted early and margins are high.

For a medicines distributor, the first complaint looks like a batch complaint while the stock sells well.

Every home from Lucknow to Lusaka knows the rule: the first termite trail costs one spray. Wait a season, and you lose the cupboard.

The first complaint is the cheapest day to act. Does your team act, or wait for a second report?

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.