For the same results, they were promoted about half as often.
A distributor with reps across three provinces promotes the same way.
In December 2010, co-founder James Liang turned the booking departments of Ctrip, China's largest travel agency, into an experiment with Stanford researchers.
Of 249 volunteers, those with even-numbered birthdays worked from home. Their performance rose about 13%.
Then came the promotion lists: 23 office workers, 17 home workers. Allowing for the better performance, the promotion penalty was roughly 50% (Nicholas Bloom, Liang, John Roberts and Zhichun Jenny Ying, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 2015).
Same managers, same figures on the screen. The researchers suspected the oldest reason there is: out of sight, out of mind.
Prevention is invisible by nature, like the stock count that stopped a shortage. Managers remember who presented in the room.
In 2021, the same company, now Trip.com, repeated the experiment with 1,612 staff on two home days a week. Promotions over the next two years were unaffected, and resignations fell by a third (Bloom, Han and Liang, Nature, 2024).
The penalty appears when a manager rarely sees the person, and fades when the manager sees everyone.
Teachers know the front bench by name, and the back bench by roll number. So do bosses.
Before your next review, list what each candidate prevented, with the evidence written down. Then compare it with who was promoted last time.
A promotion process that depends on being seen is measuring attendance.
In your company, who gets promoted: the best work, or the nearest desk?
