Thirty-four years later she ran the company.
She joined in 1980 as a co-op student and was named chief executive in December 2013.
Most boards filling the top job look outside first. The outside candidate arrives with a longer CV and a higher price.
A pharmaceutical distributor filling a country manager seat faces the same choice.
In 2011, Matthew Bidwell of Wharton compared external hires with internal movers, over six years at an investment bank.
The external hires earned about 18% more and had more education and experience. For their first two years they received lower performance ratings and left at higher rates.
A 2025 study of 11,072 restaurant managers (Jay Hardy and Anthony Klotz) adds a second effect. After the job market turned in workers' favour in 2021, insiders were more than 47% less likely to quit than outsiders.
The limit: outsiders who stayed were promoted faster afterwards, so the premium does buy something, just later than expected.
The outside hire knows the market. The insider knows which regulator, warehouse and wholesaler will call at six in the morning, and what to do about it.
Firm-specific knowledge takes about two years to buy and is the first thing to walk out of the door.
What did the last person you promoted know on day one that an outside hire would have needed a year to learn?
