Patients waited six more years. Its builder, Carillion, had gone bust.
The lowest bid can be the costliest contract.
Carillion was building two NHS hospitals, the Midland Metropolitan in Smethwick and the Royal Liverpool. In July 2017 it wrote down £845 million. On 15 January 2018 it went into liquidation, and work on both hospitals stopped.
The National Audit Office later reported one possible cause it had been told: Carillion's original pricing was too low to meet the required specification. By January 2020 the Midland Metropolitan was 44% above its original price.
Two years earlier, a rival had taken the other road. Balfour Beatty lost £187 million on the same kind of UK work in 2015. Its new chief executive, Leo Quinn, raised the margin thresholds, the least profit a new bid had to carry: "I'd rather have less business at a good margin than lots of bad business." Its order book fell 8%. By 2017 its underlying pre-tax profit was £165 million.
In December 2019, Balfour Beatty signed the contract to finish Carillion's hospital. Patients walked into the Midland Metropolitan on 6 October 2024.
Every family knows the mistri whose cheap quote needs ten more bags of cement. Economists call the trap the winner's curse: when many bidders estimate the same uncertain cost, the one who guessed lowest usually wins. A manufacturer pricing a three-year hospital supply contract faces the same arithmetic.
A low price is sometimes a better method. The UK guide on abnormally low tenders (21 October 2026) tells buyers to let a bidder show it can deliver before setting the bid aside.
The margin a bid leaves out is still paid, by someone, later.
Your bid comes in far below the next one: celebrate, or recheck the costs?
