InsightsDecisions, Risk & Governance

Lego spent two years on a brick made from plastic bottles.

By Uttam Dinodia1 min readView this post on LinkedIn

Then it found the recycled brick would have raised its carbon footprint.

In 2021, Lego showed its first prototype made from recycled PET. The story was easy to love: drink bottles turned into toys, as the company aimed to make its bricks from sustainable materials.

By September 2023, testing told a different story. To bring recycled PET up to the durability of ABS, the oil-based plastic in about 80% of its bricks, it needed extra energy for processing and drying, plus additional chemicals. Scaling it up meant changing almost everything in its factories. Lego's head of sustainability told The Guardian: "After all that, the carbon footprint would have been higher."

So Lego dropped the bottle brick and said why in public.

In 2012, accounting researchers Choi, Hecht and Tayler named the trap Lego stepped around: surrogation. A measure chosen to represent a goal slowly becomes the goal. Here, recycled content stood in for lower emissions. Once the two pointed in different directions, the team had to decide which one it actually served.

Their follow-up experiments add a practical detail. People who selected the strategy themselves surrogated less. Deliberating on it alone did not help.

Tender scorecards feel the same pull. Lowest unit price is a proxy for value, and over a few award cycles it can quietly become the value.

The case has a limit. Lego still has to find a material that works, and it says the 2032 target stands.

A proxy deserves its place only as long as it moves with the goal.

Which number on your tender scorecard has quietly become the goal: lowest unit price, on-time delivery or something else?

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.