In the study by Timo Vuori and Quy Huy, a Nokia manager remembered a deadline he thought was overly optimistic. He considered challenging it. His heart pounded. He remained silent.
Another individual was instructed to adjust chart data points to create a more favorable impression for senior executives.
The researchers connected this tendency to filter out bad news with leaders overestimating Nokia’s software abilities and focusing on short-term solutions. This offers one explanation for part of Nokia’s decline, but it is not the entire story.
When leaders review bids and delivery commitments, they often wonder: what does your team believe occurs to the individual who identifies the obstacle?
Gabriele Oettingen and Doris Mayer’s research provides a related warning. In a small study of individuals starting their careers, positive fantasies correlated with fewer job applications, fewer job offers, and lower earnings after two years. In contrast, positive expectations were linked to more offers and higher earnings.
That distinction matters. Confidence in a goal and imagining an effortless path to it are not the same.
Oettingen’s mental contrasting asks us to imagine a desired future, then to confront the present obstacle. WOOP adds an if-then plan: Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan.
For a bid review, borrow the logic:
- State the win and why it matters.
- Name the biggest obstacle, including your own reluctance to confront it.
- Decide what you will do when it appears.
For example: “If we cannot validate the delivery estimate prior to approval, we will adjust the scope before committing to it.”
Mental contrasting can also weaken commitment when expectations of success are low. It does not calculate the odds for you. Sometimes the best decision is to reconsider the goal.
A bid team that cannot identify what would cause them to lose the tender is relying on guesswork.
Optimism tends to prevail in the morning meeting once the obstacle is openly acknowledged alongside it.
The leader’s subsequent response influences whether it will be repeated.
