InsightsDecisions, Risk & Governance

Think of a decision your team has been circling for months.

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

More analysis will not end it.

In 1985, Intel had circled one for almost a year. Japanese rivals were destroying its memory-chip business. Profit had collapsed from $198 million to under $2 million. Everyone could see the numbers. Nobody could make the call.

Herbert Simon explained why, decades earlier.

In 1947, he introduced bounded rationality. Real decision-makers never have full information, unlimited time, or the capacity to process it all. So they do not optimise. They satisfice, Simon's own word: they take the first option that clears the bar. He won the Nobel Prize for it in 1978.

Intel's problem in 1985 was a cognitive blinder. Memory chips were the company's identity, and identity is hard to see past.

Then Andy Grove asked Gordon Moore one question. If the board replaced us tomorrow, what would the new chief executive do? Moore answered at once: get out of memory.

The question added no new information. It removed the blinder.

Intel exited memory and bet the company on microprocessors. The decision cost around 7,200 jobs. When the sales force told customers, the customers shrugged. One said it had taken them long enough.

This is the trap. Harvard Business Review has reported that roughly 40% of executives feel weighed down by the volume of information reaching them. The instinct is to gather more. But a limit on judgment is not lifted by volume.

One caution. A frame is not automatically the right one. Grove's question worked because the block was an identity. A decision stuck for another reason needs another rule.

Procurement runs on this. No buyer can weigh every supplier and every clause. The disciplined ones fix the must-haves and the walk-away line before the search starts, then take the first option that clears it.

When a decision will not move, more information rarely breaks the logjam. Change the rule you are deciding by.

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.