Not a mistake. A strategy.
It was attacking itself, on purpose, before anyone else could.
When Fusion launched in 2006, it cost forty percent more than the Mach3, the three-blade razor still printing money.
Gillette then ran adverts, with sports stars knocking Mach3s from men's hands, to push its own customers to trade up.
The next razor was usually in development before the last reached shelves.
By competing with itself, it held roughly seventy percent of the world market.
In 1981, Philip Kotler and Ravi Singh turned military tactics into six ways a market leader defends its position. The instinct everyone reaches for is the weakest. Position Defence: fortify the castle and hold the line. Almost every fort falls in the end. The durable move is the preemptive one. Obsolete your own product before a competitor gets the chance.
For decades it worked. Then it stopped, and the reason is the lesson.
Self-attack only protects the ground you choose to fight on.
Gillette kept attacking itself on blade count, and the price went one way: up.
That built an expensive umbrella, and in 2012 Dollar Shave Club walked in underneath it. A cheap blade, posted to your door, sold through a video mocking the very blade-count race Gillette was proud of.
A clean flank attack on price and convenience, the one ground it never defended.
Within five years its US market share fell from about seventy-one percent to fifty-nine percent. Its parent later wrote the brand down by eight billion dollars.
Attacking yourself is necessary. It is not enough. You can run a flawless defence on the ground you already win, and lose on the one you thought beneath your dignity to defend. The dangerous flank is always the flank you ignore.
So look at the product you are proudest of.
What is the one rule you are quietly counting on staying true, and what happens to your lead the day a competitor breaks it?
What is that rule for you? I would genuinely like to know.
