Ask their customers. They will say no.
In 1996, Frederick Reichheld of Bain & Company published The Loyalty Effect. His claim: a 5% improvement in customer retention could lift profits 25% to 95%. The number became one of the most quoted statistics in management.
It is also one of the most challenged. The Ehrenberg-Bass Institute later showed the figure came from a thought experiment, not empirical research. The exact multiplier was overstated.
But the direction held. Loyalty compounds. Churn erodes.
The cleanest test of the principle is the strangest business model in retail. Costco charges customers $65 to $130 a year for the right to shop. Fees account for roughly 2% of revenue and 65% of operating income. The renewal rate in the United States and Canada has held above 90% for fifteen years.
The product is the membership. The store is just the proof.
Two things this changes:
- Loyalty is not a marketing line item. It is a P&L architecture.
- The score that matters is not how loyal you think your customers are. It is how loyal they behave when prices rise.
In 2025, true brand loyalty fell to 29%, down five points from the prior year (PwC Customer Experience Survey). Nine in ten executives believed loyalty was growing in their company. Four in ten of their customers agreed.
The gap between those two numbers is the entire problem.
The entire job of leadership is to know which of the two is the truth.
How much of what you call customer loyalty is just a high cost of switching?
