InsightsLeadership & Culture

85% of leaders doubt their people are really working.

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

87% of those same people say they certainly are.

Microsoft named that gap in its 2022 Work Trend Index: productivity paranoia. It had also built a product that shows where the gap forms.

In late 2020, it launched a feature called Productivity Score. It lets managers see how individuals used email, chat and documents across 73 measures, each tied to a name. Within a week, Microsoft stripped the names out.

The instinct behind that feature is almost a hundred years old.

Between 1924 and 1932, a now-famous set of studies ran at Western Electric's Hawthorne Works near Chicago. The story that survived: output rose whether the lights went up or down, so workers were responding to the attention itself. Elton Mayo's name stuck to the idea.

One problem. The story may not be true.

In 2011, economists Steven Levitt and John List of the University of Chicago found the original lighting data in two archives and re-analysed it. There was little evidence that the effect existed. The lighting study had never even been formally published. Their verdict: the lasting lesson was the power of a good story.

Observation is never neutral. Measuring changes the thing being measured. Watch closely for productivity, and you do not get more of it. You get the performance of it.

That is the trap inside every monitoring dashboard. Numbers lift the week the tool goes live, and a leader reads it as proof that the tool works. It is not. It is the measurement reacting to itself, and the lift fades.

Anyone who runs supplier scorecards knows the smaller version. Name the three things you grade, and those three improve while the rest quietly slip.

A measure your team knows about stops being a measure. It becomes an instruction.

Look at your dashboard. Which number rose because the work improved, and which rose only because the team knew it was being watched?

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.