Geert Hofstede surveyed 117,000 IBM employees across more than 70 countries between 1967 and 1973 and derived six numbers per nation. Power distance. Individualism. Masculinity. Uncertainty avoidance. Long-term orientation. Indulgence.
These became Hofstede's Cultural Dimensions.
Half a century later, MBA programmes still teach them and executives still get briefed on them before overseas postings.
The problem is not that culture does not matter. It is that the way the scores get used is statistical malpractice.
Hofstede measured countries. Practitioners apply the scores to individuals.
Knowing India averages 77 on power distance tells you something about India. It tells you almost nothing about the engineer from Bangalore in your next meeting. The variation within most countries exceeds the difference between them.
The error has a name. The ecological fallacy: assuming what is true of a group is true of any individual in it.
Brendan McSweeney made the point in Human Relations in 2002, in a paper now cited over 2,500 times.
Hofstede himself agreed. In his own words, the dimensions distinguish populations, not individuals.
The creator of the framework said it should not be used the way it most often is.
What the framework does well is sharpen the question. Where two parties may differ, what should we ask before we assume?
What it does badly is answer it.
A country score is a starting hypothesis. The person across the table is not their passport.
