In 1985, three marketing professors at Texas A&M and Duke published a paper that changed how service organisations measure themselves. A. Parasuraman, Valarie Zeithaml and Leonard Berry called it SERVQUAL. Service quality, they argued, is not about how good you are. It is the gap between what the customer expected and what they got.
The five gaps:
- Gap 1 · what customers expect vs. what management thinks they expect
- Gap 2 · what management thinks vs. how it is specified internally
- Gap 3 · what is specified vs. what is actually delivered
- Gap 4 · what is delivered vs. what is communicated externally
- Gap 5 · the customer's expectation vs. the customer's perception
The dashboards in most service organisations track Gap 5. By the time it shows in your data, you have spent years building it.
In 1983, Horst Schulze opened the first Ritz-Carlton hotel with a rule that became famous. Every employee, from the doorman to the housekeeper, could spend up to $2,000 to resolve a guest problem without asking anyone. Forty-two years later, the rule is still in place.
The point was not the money. The point was Gap 3. Most companies tell employees to deliver service quality, then refuse to give them the authority to do so. Schulze closed Gap 3 before it opened.
The framework has critics. Cronin and Taylor (1992) argued that measuring perceptions alone (SERVPERF) outperforms gap-based scoring. They were partly right. The gap framing is still the diagnostic that matters.
PwC's research finds that 32% of customers will walk away from a brand they love after one bad experience (PwC). One Gap 3 failure is sometimes enough.
The entire job of leadership is to know which of your five gaps is the one your competitor has already closed.
Where is your widest gap?
