The harder you work to delight customers, the faster the bar moves.
In 1984, Japanese quality professor Noriaki Kano of Tokyo University of Science published Attractive Quality and Must-Be Quality. He showed that customer satisfaction is not linear. Features fall into five categories: must-be, performance, attractive, indifferent, and reverse.
The trap sits between two of those.
Attractive features do not cause dissatisfaction when absent. They surprise and excite when present. Must-be features cause dissatisfaction when absent. Their presence is barely noticed.
Attractive features do not stay attractive. They migrate.
In April 2005, Amazon Prime launched two-day shipping for $79 a year. It was attractive: surprising, delightful, almost unheard of. Twenty years later, two-day shipping is a must-be across e-commerce. Customers complain when it slips to three. Amazon spent two decades winning a race that ended at zero, and is still running.
Daniel Zacarias calls this the natural decay of delight.
Two things this changes:
- Every delighter has an expiration date the moment you ship it.
- Your competitors' delighters will become your basics whether you copy them or not.
Between 2023 and 2024, customer expectations for first-response speed rose 63% (HubSpot State of Service). AI did not invent the problem. It accelerated it.
The entire job of leadership is to know which of your delighters are already basics in someone else's product.
Which of your competitive advantages would your customer not even notice if you removed them tomorrow?
