Most customer experience problems are designed long before a customer ever speaks to an agent.
In 2003, Bernd Schmitt of Columbia Business School argued that many companies get the diagnosis backwards. We treat CX as a service-team metric: bad reviews come in, training is bought, agents are coached, and scripts are rewritten. But by the time a customer is on the phone or in chat, four out of five key CX decisions have already been made.
Here are five places to look before blaming customer service for poor reviews:
1. THE CUSTOMER
The experiential world you assume they live in.
What expectations, constraints, and emotions are you designing for?
2. THE ENVIRONMENT
Your positioning, value proposition, and overall theme.
Does your promise set up an experience your operations can actually deliver?
3. THE BRAND
The experience your brand is built to deliver.
Have you intentionally defined how it should feel to buy from, use, and even complain to you?
4. THE PLATFORM
Your operational infrastructure, scripts, KPIs, and incentives.
Are you hard-wiring behaviours that clash with what customers want and what you publicly promise?
5. THE INTERFACE
The live moment with the customer.
This is the only layer most companies coach and the one with the least strategic leverage.
A famous example: in 2014, a Comcast retention call went viral because an agent refused to cancel a customer’s account for an extended period. It sounded like one bad representative, but the real issue was upstream. The script, incentives, and brand positioning had already shaped the outcome.
Forrester has shown that CX leaders significantly outperform laggards on revenue growth. That gap is not just a service-team gap. It is a strategy gap that eventually shows up at the service team.
A poor customer experience is rarely just an interface failure.
It is usually an upstream decision that finally reaches the customer.
Which of these five layers is the weakest in your business right now?
