Attention. Interest. Desire. Action. The marketing acronym every business student learns. Coined in 1921 by C. P. Russell. The principle came from E. St. Elmo Lewis in 1898.
Read what Lewis actually wrote: "The mission of an advertisement is to attract a reader, then to interest him, then to convince him so that he will believe it."
He was describing the advertiser's job. Not the consumer's experience.
For a century, marketers have treated AIDA as a model of buyer psychology. It is a hierarchy of seller actions. Subtle but expensive distinction.
Treat a sales script as a buyer model, and every campaign pushes at every stage. The buyer is assumed to move linearly from attention to action.
The buyer does not.
In 2009, McKinsey studied real journeys across automobiles, skin care, insurance, electronics, and telecom. During active evaluation, the set of brands a buyer was considering expanded rather than narrowed. The funnel inverted.
Today buyers consult peer reviews, search results, social platforms, and AI assistants before a single decision. Information no longer flows from the seller.
Lewis was honest about what his model was. He wrote it for advertisers. McKinsey's Consumer Decision Journey, 2009, is honest about what its model is. It traces what buyers actually do.
The error was not Lewis's. It was the textbooks that promoted his sales script as buyer psychology.
A model of how to sell is not a model of how people buy.
