Eleven years later, the same company was the world’s largest producer of offshore wind. It didn’t tidy up the old business. It rebuilt the whole structure.
Not a pivot. A different company wearing the same balance sheet.
Most executives will tell you they have a sustainability strategy. Ask them what stage it is at, and the room goes quiet.
The reason is that the framework defining the stages is almost never cited.
In 2010, David Lubin and Daniel Esty stated in Harvard Business Review that sustainability is a megatrend, comparable in scope to the quality movement of the 1980s or the rise of IT in the 1990s. They outline four stages that companies typically go through:
Stage 1. Do old things in new ways. Cleaner emissions, lower energy use. Same business.
Stage 2. Do new things in new ways. New products that cut waste for the customer.
Stage 3. Transform the core. Operations rebuilt around environmental and social goals.
Stage 4. A new business model. The old company would not recognise the new one.
Almost everyone stops at Stage 1. To put it gently, most companies are still swapping fittings while telling the world they renovated. The rare cases live at Stage 4. That Danish company is the cleanest one I know.
In 2008, it was called DONG Energy. In 2009, it set a target to shift its mix to 85% renewable by 2040. It reached that target in about ten years, roughly two decades early. It sold its oil and gas business in 2017, renamed itself Ørsted, and cut its emissions intensity by 67%.
The old DONG Energy and today’s Ørsted are not the same company. That is what Stage 4 actually looks like.
Here is the trap. The marketing tells the Stage 4 story. The investment committee approves the Stage 1 budget. Your stage is not written on the slide. It is written in the capital you commit.
So be honest about your own company. Stage 1 or Stage 4?
