When one driver broke, the damage bled into the ones next to it.
Most leadership teams treat reputation as one fuzzy score. They watch it tick up or down a point and present it to the board as a health metric.
When a crisis hits, that number tells you almost nothing. Reputation doesn't drop evenly. It breaks along specific fault lines, and the average score hides which one snapped.
In 1999, Charles Fombrun (NYU) and Cees van Riel (Rotterdam) co-founded the Reputation Institute. A year later, Fombrun, Naomi Gardberg and Joy Sever published the tool that exposes those lines. The Harris-Fombrun Reputation Quotient breaks reputation into six drivers:
· Emotional Appeal. Trust, admiration, good feeling.
· Products and Services. Quality, value, innovation.
· Vision and Leadership. Direction, market opportunity.
· Workplace Environment. Management quality, employee character.
· Financial Performance. Profitability, growth, low risk.
· Social Responsibility. Causes, environment, treatment of people.
The framework still runs. The Axios Harris Poll 100, published each May, is its direct descendant. RepTrak, the firm that grew out of that 1999 institute, now scores corporate reputation for major companies worldwide.
Boeing is the cleanest current case.
After the 737 MAX crashes (346 deaths, 2018 to 2019) and the January 2024 door plug blowout, its reputation score dropped 13 points from 2019, and investors absorbed roughly $87B in losses. Net trust fell by double digits in the following month.
But the score isn't the insight. The profile is.
Boeing rated "very poor" on Trust, Citizenship and Character. It still rated "good" on Vision. Brand legacy held.
Picture a single tray with one compartment overflowing into the others. The safety driver collapsed, dragging the moral drivers down with it.
That is what the framework is for. Not a number. A diagnosis.
Most executive teams manage the average and ignore the structural crack. They cannot name which of the six drivers is their quietest vulnerability, the one a single bad week would expose.
So here's the test.
Which of the six is your organisation weakest on right now: Trust or Vision?
