In September 2015, the EPA accused Volkswagen of installing software that cheated diesel emissions tests.
The stock dropped by a third in two days. Around 11 million cars were affected. The total cost ran past €27 billion.
But the crisis didn't start in 2015. That was just the moment the world could no longer ignore it.
The signals had been building for years.
Engineers couldn't meet stricter US standards within budget. Prosecutors later said they chose software that could recognise a test and change how the car behaved during it. Bosch had warned VW in writing that using it in production would be illegal. Concerns were raised internally.
The warning signs weren't missing. The organisation wasn't built to receive them.
In The Prepared Leader (2022), Erika James and Lynn Perry Wooten draw a distinction every executive should keep.
Sudden crises arrive without warning: disasters, attacks, sabotage.
Smouldering crises grow slowly, out of organisational myopia and cultural failure. They send signals for years before anyone calls them a crisis.
Their five-phase model begins with signal detection. Before prevention. Before containment. Before recovery. Before learning.
It's the phase most leadership teams skip.
Because the real cost of a smouldering crisis isn't the press conference, the lawsuit, or the share-price drop.
It's the years when people saw fragments of the truth and the business kept operating as if nothing was wrong.
Every company has background noise. The complaint that repeats. The exception that feels minor. The shortcut that keeps working. The person who quietly stops speaking up.
So the real question isn't whether your company could survive a crisis.
It's this: name the one thing your team has quietly accepted as "just how it is." That's where the next one is already waiting.
