InsightsDecisions, Risk & Governance

The smarter you are, the better you get at defending a decision you already know is wrong.

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

A 1957 Stanford experiment proved it, and it quietly bankrupts companies every day.

Here is the mechanism behind it, and the 3-question test that stops it.

Leon Festinger called it cognitive dissonance.

When your actions contradict your beliefs, your brain feels real discomfort. To kill it, you change one of two things:

The behaviour. Hard.
The belief. Easy.

Smart people are world-class at option two.

Festinger proved it with money. People paid $1 to lie about a boring task later believed it was fun. People who paid $20 did not. The small payment left no excuse, so the brain manufactured one: "I actually enjoyed it."

The rule: the more you have personally staked on a wrong direction, the more elegant your rationalisation for staying.

Now scale that to a boardroom.

Theranos raised money from Murdoch, Kissinger, the Waltons, and the DeVos family. The blood-test device did not work, and the warning signs were there for years. When the Wall Street Journal broke the story in 2015, most insiders doubled down. Roughly $900 million evaporated by the time of the 2022 conviction.

It was not a story about one con artist. It was brilliant people who could not afford to be wrong, so they decided they weren't.

This is not a Silicon Valley problem. It is a Tuesday-morning problem.

PwC's 2026 survey of 4,454 CEOs found that only 1 in 4 has a disciplined process to stop a failing initiative. The other 3 are funding something they already know is dead because killing it would mean admitting they were wrong to start it.

The fix is not "be more objective." You can't out-discipline your own ego. You build the test into the decision before you are emotionally invested.

THE SUNK-COST CIRCUIT BREAKER (3 questions):

1. The fresh-eyes test: If I inherited this project today, knowing what I know now, would I start it? If not, you are not investing. You are rationalising.

2. The kill-criteria test: What specific result would prove this is failing? Write it down at the start. If you can't name one, you've built something unkillable.

3. The reverse-defence test: Argue the case for shutting it down as hard as you'd argue to keep it. If that feels threatening, that feeling is the dissonance talking.

The best leaders are not the ones who are right more often. They are the ones who notice they are wrong more quickly and act before rationalisation sets in.

Which of the 3 questions would kill the most projects in your world: fresh-eyes, kill-criteria, or reverse-defence?

Drop the number (1, 2, or 3) in the comments. Curious which one hits hardest.

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.