InsightsDecisions, Risk & Governance

Most boardrooms make a million-dollar decision before they've agreed on the actual problem.

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

By 9:15 a.m., they're solving the wrong thing fast.

Two strategic reasoning failures cause it. Both have a fix.

  1. Solving the wrong problem.
  2. Choosing between two bad options when a third one existed.

FIX 1: FRAME BEFORE YOU SOLVE
The E5 Approach (Binder & Watkins, HBR 2024):

EXPAND. Pull in a multidisciplinary team. All facets, no preconceptions.
EXAMINE. Dig to root cause: events, then patterns, then structures, then mental models.
EMPATHIZE. Map stakeholders by what they think, feel, want, and fear.
ELEVATE. Zoom out to the whole system (Bolman & Deal's 4 frames).
ENVISION. Backcast from a clear future state.

Most teams skip straight to ENVISION. They write a to-do list and call it a strategy.

FIX 2: SYNTHESIZE, DON'T CHOOSE
Integrative Thinking (Roger Martin, Dean of Rotman, 1999):

He studied ~50 CEOs of standout companies. The pattern: they refused to pick A or B. They built C.

SALIENCE. Embrace complexity. List ALL the variables, not just the convenient ones.
CAUSALITY. Go past linear cause-and-effect. Real problems rarely move in straight lines.
ARCHITECTURE. Sequence the decisions. Priority and timing carry the outcome.
RESOLUTION. Synthesise a third model that holds the truth from both options.

The pattern beneath both:

Great leaders are slow at the top of the funnel and fast at the bottom.

They invest time up front so they don't burn months on the wrong fix. They hold the tension in the middle so they don't ship a forced choice. Fitzgerald called holding two opposing ideas at once the test of a first-rate intelligence. Strategy is where you pass it or fail it.

What "obvious answer" did your team accept last quarter that turned out to be the wrong question?

If this is worth a second read, save it for your next planning session.

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.