Inside Theranos, scientists who flagged that the technology didn't work were interrogated about their loyalty, pushed out, or silenced.
That single choice, how you treat the people who disagree with you, is the one most teams get wrong.
Here's the part nobody tells you: the conflict was never the failure. The mismatch was.
Two London Business School researchers, Randall Peterson and Kristin Behfar, spent years studying this (HBR, March 2022). They found that every working relationship moves between 5 modes:
- Conflict (enemies) → zero-sum, defeat the other
- Competition (rivals) → protect self-interest
- Independence (neighbours) → reduce mutual impact
- Cooperation (friends) → balance self and joint goals
- Collaboration (allies) → merge interests fully
No mode is always right.
Forcing collaboration where competition fits breaks a team as fast as forcing conflict where partnership belongs.
That boardroom argument that drags on for months? Underneath, it's almost always a mode mismatch. One side assumes Collaboration. The other is already in conflict.
The skill isn't avoiding conflict. It's reading which mode the moment actually calls for, then acting on it.
Theranos got this backwards. Leadership had a vision to protect and a valuation to defend, so anyone who said the blood-testing tech wasn't ready became a threat to manage, not a colleague to listen to.
The dissenters were right. The company imploded, $9 billion in value gone, and its leaders faced criminal fraud charges.
When you treat your own people as enemies, you've already chosen the wrong mode.
Harvard's Amy Edmondson puts it bluntly: a team with no disagreement isn't healthy. It's a warning sign.
The quiet cost is staggering too. US businesses lose an estimated $359 billion a year due to poor conflict management (CPP Global).
So here's the one question worth asking in your next tense meeting:
Are we enemies, rivals, neighbours, friends, or allies right now?
Drop the mode you're seeing on your team in the comments. I read everyone.
♻️ Repost this if your team needs the reminder.
