InsightsLeadership & Culture

Most leaders think confidentiality is a promise.

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

It isn't. It's a condition. And the moment you forget that, loyalty quietly turns into complicity.

Here's the line most people never learn until they're standing on it:

"The protective privilege ends where the public peril begins."

Justice Tobriner wrote that in 1976, after Tarasoff v. Regents. A therapist knew a patient had named a victim. He said nothing. The victim died.

The case rewrote professional confidentiality and exposed a truth most leaders avoid: confidentiality is not absolute. Treating it as if it isn't ethics. It's mistaken loyalty.

Harvard ethicist Sissela Bok showed why. Confidentiality rests on three things:

  1. Autonomy over your own information
  2. Respect for shared trust
  3. The promise you actually made

None of the three is absolute. When confidentiality stops protecting relationships and starts protecting harm, the duty inverts. Silence becomes the betrayal, not disclosure.

This isn't theory. It's already law.

In 1996, Dr. Jeffrey Wigand broke his NDA on 60 Minutes to reveal his employer had manipulated nicotine. The case against him collapsed inside the tobacco Master Settlement: 46 state attorneys general, at least $206 billion.

Today, SEC Rule 21F-17 bars NDAs from silencing employees who report securities violations. JP Morgan paid $18 million in 2024 for trying.

So here's a simple test for the next time an agreement and your conscience point in different directions.

Before you stay silent, ask three questions:

  1. Who is protected by my silence: a relationship, or a harm?
  2. If this surfaced publicly, would I defend the silence or the disclosure?
  3. Is there a law that has already decided this for me?

The hardest leadership calls aren't between right and wrong. They sit between two duties that have stopped pointing in the same direction.

Save the three questions. You'll need them sooner than you think.

Have you ever seen silence defended as "loyalty" when it was really something else? No names needed.

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.