InsightsDecisions, Risk & Governance

The deadliest words in any boardroom:

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

"I thought we all agreed."

In 1961, John F. Kennedy and his cabinet of brilliant advisors approved the Bay of Pigs invasion.

1,400 men landed in Cuba. 1,200 were captured or killed within 72 hours.

Years later, advisor Arthur Schlesinger Jr. wrote:

"Had one senior advisor opposed the adventure, I believe Kennedy would have canceled it. No one spoke against it."

No one.

That disaster inspired Groupthink, the theory developed by Yale psychologist Irving Janis (1972).

His definition:
A mode of thinking where the drive for unanimity overrides the motivation to realistically appraise alternatives.

Eight symptoms to recognise in your own meetings:

1 Illusion of invulnerability → "We don't make mistakes."
2 Belief in our own morality → "We are clearly right."
3 Collective rationalisation → "We already looked at the risks."
4 Out-group stereotyping → "They just don't get it."
5 Self-censorship → "I had doubts but stayed quiet."
6 Illusion of unanimity → "Silence means agreement."
7 Pressure on dissenters → "Are you really a team player?"
8 Self-appointed mindguards → "Let's not bother the boss with this."

Groupthink has been blamed for Pearl Harbour, the Challenger explosion, Enron's $74 billion collapse, Kodak killing its own digital camera invention, and the 2008 subprime crisis.

Now the JFK paradox:

The same advisors who approved the Bay of Pigs also handled the Cuban Missile Crisis, brilliantly.

What changed?

Kennedy stopped attending some meetings. He invited outside experts. He appointed his brother as devil's advocate. He split the room into rival subgroups.

Same people. Different process. Opposite result.

Groupthink is not a people problem. It is a meeting design problem.

When was the last time someone actually disagreed with you in a meeting?

If you cannot remember, you are not leading a team.

You are chairing a chorus.

♻️ Repost if your team needs a devil's advocate this week.

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.