InsightsLeadership & Culture

A company once put "We value honesty" on the lobby wall.

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

The same week, a manager told her team to hide a missed deadline from the client.

That gap is the whole problem with company values.

Your values aren't your culture. They're what you wish your culture was.

Edgar Schein, the MIT professor who basically founded the field, explained why back in 1985. Every organisation runs on three levels. Most leaders manage only the top one.

Level 1 - Artifacts (what you see)
Dress codes, slogans, office snacks, rituals. Easy to change. Signals almost nothing about how the place actually works.

Level 2 - Espoused Values (what you say)
Mission statements, wall posters, all-hands decks. The gap between what's on the poster and what actually happens is exactly where cynicism grows.

Level 3 - Basic Assumptions (what you believe)
The unspoken rules. Nobody questions the "that's just how we do things here". This is your real culture, and most of it is invisible even to the people living inside it.

Here's why most culture initiatives quietly fail.

They stop at Level 1. Repaint the walls. Relaunch the values. Reword the slogans. Meanwhile, Level 3, the part that actually drives behaviour, stays completely untouched.

A simple way to spot the gap:

  • The poster says, "Speak up." Do people actually speak up in the meeting, or only afterwards in the hallway?
  • The values say "collaboration." But do promotions reward the lone hero or the team player?
  • The strategy says "innovation." So, what happens to the person whose bold experiment fails?

When the answers don't match the posters, you don't have a values problem. You have a Level 3 problem.

As Schein put it: "If you do not manage culture, it manages you."

Culture doesn't change when you write new values. It changes when people stop being afraid of what happens if they actually live them.

If you've ever watched a company say one thing and reward another, you already know which level was really in charge.

Which of the three levels does your team spend the most energy on, and which one actually runs the show? Curious to hear what you've seen.

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.