That fix has not worked for two decades.
In a March 2022 HBR article, What Is the Purpose of Your Purpose?, Knowles, Hunsaker, Grove and James argued the problem is not absence. It is confusion. The word "purpose" gets used for three completely different jobs, often inside the same statement.
- Purpose as Competence. The function the product or service serves. Mercedes: "First Move the World."
- Purpose as Culture. The intent with which the company is run. Zappos: "To Live and Deliver WOW."
- Purpose as Cause. The social good the company aspires to. Tesla: "To accelerate the world's transition to sustainable energy."
Three distinct things. Three different audiences. Three different tests of authenticity.
The trap is the kitchen-sink statement that tries to do all three at once. It almost always sounds inspiring and almost never settles a decision.
Knowles' sharper claim is that not every company should aim for a Cause-based purpose. The current fashion forces every business to declare it is "saving the world." Few authentically can. Forcing the framing breeds cynicism, particularly when Culture or Competence would have been the honest answer.
A pragmatic Competence purpose, well-articulated, beats a borrowed Cause purpose written for the website.
Which kind of purpose is your organisation actually claiming, and does the rest of the company know which one to deliver?
