In best-practice organisations, the figure is 70%. (Gallup, 2025)
The gap is not pay, perks, or purpose statements. It is the assumption sitting beneath every management decision.
In The Human Side of Enterprise (1960), MIT's Douglas McGregor named two assumptions:
- Theory X: people dislike work. They must be commanded, controlled, and threatened.
- Theory Y: people are self-motivated and self-directed. They commit to objectives they help define.
Bottom-up management is Theory Y in practice.
In 1982, Ricardo Semler took over Semco at age 21. On his first day, he fired 60% of the top managers. Over two decades, he reduced the number of layers of management from twelve to three. Workers set their own salaries. Employees vote on hires, fires, and strategy. All financial data is public.
Revenue grew from $4 million to $212 million. Headcount went from 90 to 3,000-plus. Average annual growth: 47%.
Critics are right that bottom-up is slow. Consensus takes longer than command. A 2025 California Management Review study of 108 managers and frontline employees across four global banks found managers consistently perceive their organisations as more bottom-up than employees feel.
The gap is not the framework. It is leaders who say Theory Y and act Theory X.
Trust is not a value statement. It is what you do when no one is watching the meeting.
What is the gap between what your organisation says about its people and how it decides about them?
