Every car that failed would now cost Hyundai money.
By 1998, its US sales had fallen to about 90,000 cars. Talk-show hosts had used the brand as a punchline for years, and buyers feared the cars would not last.
That year, Hyundai's American arm launched a 10-year, 100,000-mile powertrain warranty, the most generous in the industry. US sales rose 312% between 1999 and 2002. In 2004, J.D. Power ranked its initial quality level with Honda.
In 1973, economist Michael Spence explained why this kind of answer works. A signal persuades only when it is too costly to fake. Any carmaker can claim reliability in an advertisement. Only one that expects few failures can afford to pay for a decade of repairs.
The signal worked inside the company too. John Krafcik, later head of Hyundai's US business, described the warranty as a clarifier for its engineers, who now had to design parts to last. Reported quality problems fell 42% between 1998 and 2002.
That is the caveat. A costly promise protects a reputation only when the product changes behind it. Otherwise, the warranty becomes a bill.
Rebuttals are cheap to write and cheap to ignore. A promise that costs you money every time you are wrong is the reply people believe.
