The risk is finding that out only after you have committed.
In September 2011, Netflix announced plans to separate its DVD-by-mail service under a new name: Qwikster. Customers using DVDs and streaming would have to manage two websites. Netflix reversed the plan three weeks later, before launch.
Reed Hastings later wrote that dozens of managers and VPs had doubted the idea but stayed quiet. Some trusted his judgment over their own; others took colleagues' silence as agreement.
He linked that experience to Netflix's practice of actively seeking dissent. Its current culture memo asks decision-makers to seek different views before making the call.
Invite objections early and examine them without making the discussion personal. A meeting can end without everyone agreeing. It should still end with everyone respected.
The research adds a caution. A 2012 review of 116 studies by de Wit, Greer and Jehn linked personal conflict with poorer team outcomes. Disagreement about the work was more positively related to performance when it was less tied to personal friction. That does not mean more disagreement automatically produces better decisions.
At your next decision meeting, make room for three questions:
- Which assumption do you think is wrong?
- What evidence would change our minds?
- Who will decide, and when will we review the result?
Address the strongest objection when explaining the decision: what changed, or why you chose to proceed. Then follow through professionally, including when your preferred option was not chosen.
