InsightsSupply Chain & Operations

Target opened 124 stores in Canada on almost the same day.

By Uttam Dinodia1 min readView this post on LinkedIn

Two years later, every one of them was shut.

The plan had looked rigorous. A $1.8 billion store footprint bought from Zellers, three distribution centres, and a full forecasting system. It scored well on every number that mattered: market size, brand recognition, speed to scale.

What nobody scored was the downside.

The supply chain had never been tested at a national scale. When the data feeding it turned out to be wrong, shelves sat empty while warehouses overflowed. By January 2015, the loss had passed $2 billion.

In 1965, Charles Kepner and Benjamin Tregoe wrote The Rational Manager. Their method is still taught everywhere: list your musts, weigh your wants, score each option, and choose the option with the highest total.

But the step that would have saved Target is the one teams routinely skip. Once you have the top option, you are meant to list its adverse consequences and rate each one for probability and severity. You score the damage the winning choice could do, not just the value it could create.

McKinsey's global survey found that only one in five organisations believes they make good decisions. The skipped step is usually this one.

A weighted matrix is very good at telling you which option wins. It says almost nothing about which option you can survive being wrong about.

Target had the higher-scoring plan. It did not have the survivable one. A phased rollout would have lost on speed and exposed the broken supply chain in ten stores, not in a hundred.

The numbers tell you what to choose. The downside tells you what you can afford to lose.

On your last major decision, did anyone price the downside, or only the upside?

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.