InsightsStrategy & Competition

Strategy is not doing what your competitors do better. It is doing what your competitors do not.

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

In 1985, Michael Porter of Harvard Business School published Competitive Advantage. Inside was a diagram that became the most-cited tool in strategy: the Value Chain.

No company is a single thing. Every company is a sequence of nine activities. Five primary:

  • Inbound logistics
  • Operations
  • Outbound logistics
  • Marketing and sales
  • Service

Four support:

  • Firm infrastructure
  • Human resource management
  • Technology development
  • Procurement

Porter argued that competitive advantage comes from one of two paths. Doing the same activities at a lower cost or doing a different set of activities altogether.

In his 1996 HBR paper What Is Strategy?, Porter offered the example. IKEA does not sell furniture better than its competitors. IKEA sells different furniture: flat-packed, assembled by customers, sold from self-service warehouses, and paired with childcare so parents can shop. The activities reinforce each other. The competitor who copies one without the others bears the cost of disruption but gets none of the advantage.

Stabell and Fjeldstad (1998) argued that Porter's framework breaks down for services and networks. They proposed the Value Shop and the Value Network as extensions. They were partly right. The original framing still holds for any business that turns inputs into outputs.

Forty years on, the question still cuts. McKinsey research on operating-model transformation consistently shows that cost optimisation produces incremental gains, while activity reconfiguration produces step changes (McKinsey). Most companies are doing the first. The companies that win this decade are doing the second.

The entire job of leadership is to know whether your value chain is engineered for the world that exists, or the world you have always operated in.

Which of your nine activities is one you would do exactly the same way if you were starting today?

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.