InsightsProcurement & Tenders

Buying analytics tools for a chaotic procurement team is not a transformation.

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

It is bolting more machinery onto a process that was already coming apart.

Most procurement teams don't lack process.
They lack maturity.

Across hundreds of deals, the same pattern repeats.

The SOP binder is thick. The audit log is empty.
Process exists on paper. Discipline doesn't.

The Capability Maturity Model, built for software engineering at Carnegie Mellon and formalised by Watts Humphrey in 1991, diagnoses exactly where a function actually operates.

Not where it says it operates.

Five levels. No shortcuts.

  1. Initial → Ad hoc. Heroic individuals. Outcomes vary wildly.
  2. Repeatable → Basic processes exist, and the discipline to follow them.
  3. Defined → Processes are documented, standardised, integrated across functions.
  4. Managed → Processes are measured. Data is used to control, not just filed.
  5. Optimising → Continuous improvement. Feedback loops. Deliberate pilots of new tools.

Here is the trap.

They buy software, templates and training designed for Level 4.
Then install it on top of a Level 1 reality.

Adding process to chaos does not produce order.
It produces faster chaos.

You can see it in any office where the dashboards are glowing, the policy shelves are full, and the only number that moves is the count of missed deadlines.

The real lesson from CMM is uncomfortable:

Maturity is earned in sequence.
A function at Level 2 cannot jump to Level 5. It can only reach Level 3.

The discipline built at each level is the foundation for the next.

A Level 1 tender shop buying Level 4 analytics is not modernising.
It is spending capital to watch itself fail in higher resolution.

So before the next tool, the next platform, the next manual, one honest question:

Where does your procurement function actually sit today, Level 1 or Level 4?

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.