Ask one why it failed, and they describe the partner. Ask the partner, and they describe a completely different organisation.
Same alliance. Two accounts that don't even match.
Strategic alliances grow by about 25% a year and now account for up to a third of revenue at many firms. Yet the failure rate has not moved in two decades. It still sits between 60% and 70%.
We have gotten very good at writing the contract. We have gotten no better at building the alliance.
Researchers can name a dozen forms of partnership: joint ventures, licensing, franchising, and R&D consortia. Useful for labelling the structure. Useless for explaining why it dies.
Doz and Hamel gave the sharper test. Three things decide whether an alliance survives:
- Complementarity. Each side brings capabilities the other lacks.
- Relational capital. Trust accumulated over years of joint work.
- Governance. The system that decides who decides what.
Most leaders obsess over the first two and quietly ignore the third. Then they are surprised when the third one kills the deal.
Renault and Nissan show how powerful, and how fragile, this really is.
In 1999, Renault paid $5.4 billion for 36.8% of Nissan, which was near bankrupt. By 2017, it was the world's largest automotive alliance by light-vehicle sales, generating €5.7 billion in annual synergies. A masterpiece of complementarity.
Then, in November 2018, its architect Carlos Ghosn was arrested in Tokyo.
What followed was not a structural failure. It was corporate infighting, national rivalry, and political paranoia. By 2023, Renault had cut its stake to 15%, and the partners had reset the alliance on far looser terms.
Ghosn's own verdict, from exile:
"This kind of cross-holding can exist only if there is trust between the parties. When the trust disappears, it's over."
Twenty years to build the structure. Less than two to burn through the trust.
The contract records the alliance. The trust is what keeps it standing.
And when the trust cracks, no clause holds up the ceiling.
When an alliance dies, what usually breaks first?
The contract, or the trust?
