InsightsPeople, Teams & Careers

Adobe's head of HR announced the end of annual reviews to a reporter.

By Uttam Dinodia2 min readView this post on LinkedIn

She had not told her own CEO.

It was March 2012. Donna Morris, then Adobe's head of HR, let it slip in an interview in India. By the next morning, it was public, and there was no walking it back.

And she knew exactly what would follow: thousands of uncomfortable conversations with managers who treated the review as the spine of their authority.

Take away the form, and all that is left is the conversation.

That is exactly where most leaders freeze.

Monique Valcour's work in Harvard Business Review (2017) gives that conversation a structure. It is practical and unforgiving.

Before the conversation

  • Shift into partnership, not opposition.
  • Reframe the goal to learn, not to convince.
  • Say your intention out loud.
  • Acknowledge your own part in the problem.

During the conversation

  • Drop your assumptions about what the other person thinks.
  • Avoid the ABCDs: Blame, Contempt, Defensiveness, Stonewalling.
  • Hold the issue with openness and curiosity.
  • Seek input, not just agreement.

Those four behaviours come from John Gottman's research on what breaks relationships down. Valcour simply moved the diagnostic into the workplace.

Adobe then did what most companies only talk about.

By late 2012, annual reviews were gone, replaced by continuous Check-ins. Voluntary attrition fell sharply. Involuntary departures rose, because managers were finally having the performance conversations they had spent years postponing.

The problem was never the form. It was the silence the form allowed.

VitalSmarts surveyed more than 1,000 employees and found that each difficult conversation people avoid costs an organisation roughly $7,500 and more than seven working days due to delays, rework, and stress.

Every conversation you postpone is a problem you are quietly financing.

So one simple question:

What conversation are you avoiding right now?

Uttam Dinodia

Uttam Dinodia

Pharmaceutical Business Consultant & Executive Director, A One Afro Limited

Over 22 years in pharmaceutical supply. Helps international manufacturers and Zambian institutions with public tenders, ZAMRA regulatory pathways and distribution.