"Not satisfied? Don't pay. Scratch it out, write a note, send us the balance."
No refund forms. No customer service calls. The customer decides.
The company is Granite Rock, a 125-year-old California rock quarry.
The result: they gained market share while charging 6% above competitors. They won the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award.
Why?
Granite Rock had an audacious goal: to match Nordstrom on customer service.
They did not write the goal on a wall. They gave it teeth.
In 1999, Stanford Professor Jim Collins published this idea in the Harvard Business Review as Catalytic Mechanisms, the missing link between goals and results.
Five traits that separate real mechanisms from corporate theatre:
1 UNPREDICTABLE RESULTS
The process does not dictate the answer. People invent it.
2 DISTRIBUTES POWER
Those who hold power give some of it up.
3 HAS TEETH
You cannot back out. The mechanism forces the outcome.
4 EJECTS VIRUSES
People misaligned with the values leave on their own.
5 ONGOING EFFECT
Not a workshop. A decade of gravity.
The legendary examples:
3M (1956): Scientists get 15% of paid time to build whatever they want. No approval needed. Result: Post-it Notes, reflective license plates, surgical devices. Sales grew 40 times over.
Nucor Steel: When profits fall, workers lose 25%, plant managers lose 40%, executives lose 60%. In 1982, CEO Ken Iverson's pay dropped 75%. The pain flows up, not down.
W.L. Gore: Employees effectively fire their boss by choosing to follow someone else. "You are a leader if and only if people choose to follow you."
Collins' Stanford classroom: Every student got a red flag. Anyone could raise it anytime, say anything, no consequences. One student told him his teaching was killing their thinking. He changed.
Notice what every mechanism shares.
It turns words into a rule the system cannot wriggle out of.
BHAGs are the company's wildest dreams. Catalytic mechanisms are their foundations.
Most strategies fail quietly. The slides are approved, the values are framed on the wall, and six months later nothing has changed.
The mechanism is the difference between hope and gravity.
What is one catalytic mechanism your organization has? If none, which should it build?
♻️ Repost for the leader still running strategy on slides instead of teeth.
